Choosing the right cartridge for your needs can feel overwhelming, especially when faced with similar options like the 5.7x28mm and the .17 HMR. Both are known for their accuracy and velocity, but they cater to vastly different applications. This detailed comparison will help you understand the key differences and decide which cartridge best suits your purpose.
Understanding the Contenders
The 5.7x28mm is a relatively high-velocity, small-caliber cartridge initially designed for military and law enforcement applications. Its small size and high velocity offer impressive penetration and stopping power at close to medium ranges. It's known for its use in personal defense weapons like the FN P90 and FN Five-seveN pistol.
The .17 HMR (.17 Hornet Magnum) is a rimfire cartridge significantly smaller than the 5.7x28mm, commonly used for small game hunting and target shooting. Its high velocity and flat trajectory make it accurate at longer ranges compared to other rimfire rounds. Its popularity stems from its affordability and ease of use.
Key Differences: A Head-to-Head Comparison
| Feature | 5.7x28mm | .17 HMR |
|---|---|---|
| Caliber | 5.7mm (0.224 inch) | 4.5mm (0.172 inch) |
| Type | Centerfire | Rimfire |
| Velocity | Significantly higher | High, but less than 5.7x28mm |
| Stopping Power | Higher, better penetration | Lower, suitable for small game |
| Recoil | Moderate | Very low |
| Cost per Round | Higher | Lower |
| Availability | More readily available in some regions | Widely available |
| Applications | Personal defense, law enforcement, varmint hunting | Small game hunting, target shooting |
| Effective Range | Longer | Shorter, but accurate at longer ranges for its class |
5.7x28mm: Advantages and Disadvantages
Advantages:
- Higher Stopping Power: The 5.7x28mm's higher velocity and heavier bullet provide superior penetration and stopping power compared to the .17 HMR.
- Longer Effective Range: It's effective at considerably longer ranges.
- Greater Versatility: Suitable for self-defense, law enforcement, and varmint hunting.
Disadvantages:
- Higher Cost: Ammunition for the 5.7x28mm is generally more expensive.
- More Recoil: It possesses more recoil than the .17 HMR.
- Requires Centerfire Firearms: This limits the firearm options.
.17 HMR: Advantages and Disadvantages
Advantages:
- Lower Cost: .17 HMR ammunition is significantly cheaper.
- Very Low Recoil: Ideal for new shooters and those sensitive to recoil.
- High Accuracy: Known for its accuracy at its effective range.
- Wide Availability: Ammunition and firearms are readily available.
Disadvantages:
- Limited Stopping Power: Insufficient for larger game or self-defense.
- Shorter Effective Range: Accuracy degrades significantly at longer distances compared to the 5.7x28mm.
Conclusion: Choosing the Right Cartridge
The choice between the 5.7x28mm and the .17 HMR hinges entirely on your intended use.
-
Choose the 5.7x28mm if: You need higher stopping power, a longer effective range, and are willing to pay more for ammunition. This cartridge excels in self-defense, law enforcement, and varmint control.
-
Choose the .17 HMR if: You prioritize affordability, low recoil, high accuracy at shorter to medium ranges, and are focused on small game hunting or target practice. This cartridge is perfect for recreational shooting and hunting smaller animals.
Careful consideration of these factors will guide you toward the optimal cartridge for your specific requirements. Remember to always practice safe firearm handling and consult relevant regulations before using any firearm.
