The Smith & Wesson Model 586 is a legendary revolver, renowned for its accuracy, reliability, and robust construction. For decades, it's been a favorite among law enforcement, competitive shooters, and collectors alike. But what do real-world users think? This in-depth review will delve into various aspects of the 586, examining user experiences, common praises, and potential drawbacks to help you determine if this classic is the right firearm for you.
Performance and Accuracy: The 586's Strong Suit
The 586's reputation for accuracy is well-deserved. Many reviews highlight its exceptional balance and trigger pull, contributing to consistent shot placement. The robust construction, featuring a heavy barrel and frame, minimizes recoil, allowing for quicker follow-up shots and improved target acquisition. This makes it ideal for both target practice and self-defense situations. The .357 Magnum chambering offers stopping power, while the ability to also shoot .38 Special rounds provides versatility. Users consistently praise the 586's performance in various shooting disciplines, from informal plinking to competitive shooting.
Key Features Contributing to Accuracy:
- Heavy Barrel: Reduces muzzle flip and improves accuracy.
- Adjustable Sights: Allow for precise sight adjustments to suit individual preferences and shooting styles.
- Smooth Action: Contributes to a crisp trigger pull and enhanced accuracy.
Reliability and Durability: Built to Last
Smith & Wesson is known for producing durable firearms, and the 586 is no exception. Reviews consistently mention its reliability, even under harsh conditions. The revolver's robust construction ensures it can withstand significant use and abuse, making it a dependable firearm for both casual shooters and professionals. The full-lug barrel and tight tolerances contribute significantly to its long-term reliability. Many users report owning their 586s for years, even decades, with minimal maintenance.
Factors Contributing to Reliability:
- High-Quality Materials: Smith & Wesson uses durable materials in the 586's construction.
- Precise Manufacturing: Tight tolerances ensure reliable function.
- Simple Design: The revolver's relatively simple mechanism reduces the chance of malfunctions.
Ergonomics and Handling: A Comfortable Shooting Experience
While the weight of the 586 might be considered a drawback by some, many users find it contributes to comfortable handling and reduced recoil. The grip is generally well-regarded, providing a secure and comfortable hold. However, grip preference is subjective, and some users might find it necessary to replace the factory grip with an aftermarket option to achieve optimal comfort and control.
Ergonomic Considerations:
- Weight: Contributes to reduced recoil but might be considered heavy by some shooters.
- Grip: Generally well-regarded but can be subjective; aftermarket grips are readily available.
- Balance: The 586's balance often receives high praise, enhancing its shootability.
Potential Drawbacks: Addressing the Criticisms
While overwhelmingly positive, some reviews mention potential drawbacks. The weight, as mentioned, can be a concern for some users, particularly those with smaller hands or who prefer lighter firearms. The cost of the 586 can also be a factor, making it a more significant investment compared to some other revolvers. Additionally, the maintenance requirements, although minimal, shouldn't be overlooked. Regular cleaning and lubrication are essential to ensure optimal performance and longevity.
Conclusion: Is the Smith & Wesson 586 Right for You?
The Smith & Wesson Model 586 is a classic revolver that continues to impress. Its accuracy, reliability, and durability are consistently highlighted in user reviews. While the weight and cost might be deterrents for some, the overall performance and quality make it a worthy investment for many. If you're seeking a robust, accurate, and reliable revolver for target shooting, hunting, or self-defense, the 586 deserves serious consideration. However, careful consideration of your individual needs and preferences is always recommended before making a purchase. This detailed review provides a comprehensive overview to help inform your decision.
