Beretta 686 Onyx vs. Silver Pigeon: A Detailed Comparison for the Discerning Shotgunner
Choosing between the Beretta 686 Onyx and the Silver Pigeon can feel overwhelming. Both are renowned over-and-under shotguns from a prestigious manufacturer, but subtle differences cater to distinct shooting styles and preferences. This in-depth comparison will help you determine which gun best fits your needs.
Understanding the Target Audience: This comparison is geared towards experienced and prospective shotgun owners familiar with the basics of over-and-under shotguns. We'll delve into specific features and nuances to aid in informed decision-making.
I. Design and Aesthetics:
-
Beretta 686 Onyx: The Onyx boasts a more utilitarian design. It emphasizes functionality over elaborate ornamentation. The receiver is typically finished in a durable, matte black, offering a no-nonsense aesthetic. This translates to a lower price point, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious shooters.
-
Beretta Silver Pigeon: The Silver Pigeon takes a step up in terms of aesthetics. It features a more ornate receiver, often with beautiful scrollwork engraving. The finish is typically higher-grade, often a polished blued steel or nickel, giving it a more elegant and refined look. This enhanced aesthetic comes with a corresponding increase in price.
II. Build Quality and Materials:
Both the Onyx and the Silver Pigeon are built to Beretta's exacting standards, utilizing high-quality materials. However, subtle differences exist:
- Steel: Both shotguns utilize high-strength steel for the receiver and barrels, ensuring durability and longevity.
- Wood: The Onyx typically features a more straightforward, less-figured wood stock, often walnut. The Silver Pigeon typically employs higher-grade, more attractively figured walnut, enhancing the overall aesthetic appeal.
- Overall Construction: While both are robust, the Silver Pigeon often exhibits finer details in its construction, contributing to its perceived higher quality and price.
III. Features and Functionality:
The core functionality remains similar:
- Action: Both are reliable, robust, and easily maintained break-action over-and-under shotguns.
- Ejectors: Both models usually come equipped with automatic ejectors, facilitating quick reloading.
- Safety: Both feature a tang-mounted safety.
- Chokes: Both typically accept interchangeable chokes (often Beretta Mobil chokes), allowing shooters to adjust the shot pattern to suit different hunting situations or target shooting.
Key Difference: The Silver Pigeon might include more premium features depending on the specific model, such as higher-grade wood, more intricate engraving, or other embellishments.
IV. Price and Value:
- Beretta 686 Onyx: Represents excellent value for its price. It delivers reliable performance and Beretta quality without the premium cost of more ornate models.
- Beretta Silver Pigeon: Sits at a higher price point, reflecting the enhanced aesthetics, materials, and potentially added features.
V. Which Shotgun is Right for You?
The choice hinges on your priorities:
- Choose the Beretta 686 Onyx if: You prioritize functionality, durability, and value for money. You're a practical shooter who values performance over elaborate aesthetics.
- Choose the Beretta Silver Pigeon if: You appreciate a more refined aesthetic, are willing to pay a premium for higher-grade materials and enhanced features, and want a shotgun that makes a statement.
VI. Conclusion:
Both the Beretta 686 Onyx and Silver Pigeon are exceptional shotguns. The best choice depends entirely on your individual needs and preferences. Carefully consider your budget, shooting style, and desired aesthetics before making your final decision. Consider handling both models if possible to get a feel for their fit and balance. Ultimately, the "best" shotgun is the one that feels right in your hands and performs flawlessly in the field.
