Is a .17 HMR Good for Squirrel Hunting? A Comprehensive Guide
The .17 HMR (Hornady Magnum Rimfire) is a popular cartridge known for its impressive accuracy and flat trajectory, making it a frequent contender in the small game hunting world. But is it the right choice for squirrel hunting? The answer, as with most hunting questions, is nuanced and depends on several factors. Let's delve into the pros and cons to help you decide.
The Advantages of Using a .17 HMR for Squirrel Hunting
-
Accuracy and Range: The .17 HMR boasts superior accuracy compared to many other rimfire rounds. Its flat trajectory allows for precise shots at longer ranges than you'd typically achieve with a .22 LR, making it effective even on squirrels in taller trees or across wider distances. This is particularly beneficial in areas with more open spaces.
-
Clean Kills: The higher velocity of the .17 HMR results in a cleaner, more humane kill, minimizing suffering for the animal. Proper shot placement is crucial, of course, but the increased energy transfer often leads to a quicker, more decisive outcome.
-
Reduced Noise (Compared to Centerfire): While not as quiet as a .22 LR, the .17 HMR offers a noticeable reduction in noise compared to centerfire cartridges, making it a more suitable choice in areas with noise restrictions or where you need to maintain stealth.
-
Variety of Ammunition: Numerous manufacturers produce .17 HMR ammunition, offering choices in bullet weight, type (hollow point, solid point, etc.), and price point, allowing you to select the best option for your specific hunting needs.
The Disadvantages of Using a .17 HMR for Squirrel Hunting
-
Cost: .17 HMR ammunition is generally more expensive than .22 LR, which can be a significant factor for those hunting frequently or on a budget.
-
Overkill Potential: The .17 HMR's power can be excessive for squirrels, especially at close ranges. A poorly placed shot can cause significant damage and potentially ruin a significant portion of the meat. This makes precise shot placement paramount.
-
Ricochet Risk: The higher velocity can increase the risk of ricochets, particularly off branches or rocks, posing a potential safety hazard to the hunter or others in the vicinity.
-
More Recoil: Compared to a .22 LR, the .17 HMR has more recoil, potentially making it less comfortable for new shooters or those with sensitivity to recoil.
Choosing the Right Cartridge: .17 HMR vs. .22 LR
The .22 LR remains a popular and effective choice for squirrel hunting, due to its lower cost, reduced recoil, and quieter operation. It's an excellent choice for those seeking a more economical option or who prioritize a less jarring shooting experience. However, the .17 HMR provides a clear advantage in accuracy and range.
Conclusion: Is a .17 HMR Good for Squirrel Hunting?
Ultimately, whether a .17 HMR is "good" for squirrel hunting depends on your priorities, hunting style, and shooting skills. If accuracy and range are paramount and you're comfortable with the higher cost and recoil, the .17 HMR is a viable and potentially superior option. However, if budget and recoil are significant considerations, or if you're a novice hunter, the .22 LR might be a better starting point. Remember that responsible hunting practices, including accurate shot placement and ethical harvesting, are crucial regardless of the cartridge used. Always prioritize safety and responsible firearm handling.
