Choosing between the Ruger GP100 and the Smith & Wesson 686 is a common dilemma for revolver enthusiasts. Both are renowned for their reliability, durability, and accuracy, making them popular choices for target shooting, hunting, and self-defense. This in-depth comparison will analyze key features, helping you determine which revolver best suits your needs and preferences.
Key Differences: A Head-to-Head Look
Both the GP100 and the 686 are .357 Magnum revolvers capable of firing .38 Special ammunition. However, several key differences set them apart:
1. Frame Material and Construction:
- Ruger GP100: Typically features a rugged, stainless steel construction known for its strength and resistance to wear and tear. The GP100's construction often leads to a slightly heavier feel.
- Smith & Wesson 686: Also commonly available in stainless steel, the 686 often boasts a slightly more refined and polished finish. While equally durable, some perceive the 686 to have a sleeker profile.
2. Action:
- Ruger GP100: Known for its strong, reliable action. The GP100's double-action trigger pull can be a bit heavier than the 686's, but this is often considered a matter of personal preference. Ruger's design emphasis is on robust functionality.
- Smith & Wesson 686: The 686 generally offers a smoother double-action trigger pull, often appreciated by those prioritizing a more refined shooting experience. The single-action trigger is typically crisper as well. Smith & Wesson's reputation often centers around a more refined and comfortable shooting experience.
3. Weight and Size:
- Ruger GP100: Generally heavier than the 686, contributing to reduced felt recoil. This added weight, however, can make it less comfortable for extended shooting sessions for some users.
- Smith & Wesson 686: Often lighter and more compact than the GP100, making it easier to carry concealed (depending on barrel length) and handle during extended shooting sessions.
4. Features and Options:
- Ruger GP100: Offers a range of barrel lengths and configurations, including variations with adjustable sights. Ruger's design often prioritizes functionality over aesthetic refinement.
- Smith & Wesson 686: Also offers various barrel lengths and configurations, often with a wider selection of finishes and grips. Smith & Wesson frequently incorporates more aesthetic options and features.
5. Price:
- Both revolvers are generally in a similar price range, with fluctuations based on specific configurations and retailer. Minor price differences should not be the sole determining factor in your decision.
Which Revolver is Right for You?
The best revolver depends heavily on individual needs and preferences:
-
Choose the Ruger GP100 if: You prioritize rugged durability, significant recoil reduction, and a revolver built to withstand heavy use. The GP100's robust design makes it ideal for harsh conditions and those who prioritize function above all else.
-
Choose the Smith & Wesson 686 if: You value a smoother trigger pull, lighter weight, and a more refined shooting experience. The 686's sleek design and potentially easier handling might be more appealing for target shooting or concealed carry (depending on barrel length).
Beyond the Specs: Consider These Factors
- Intended Use: Will this be primarily a range gun, a hunting firearm, or a self-defense weapon? Your intended use will significantly influence your choice.
- Shooting Experience: Beginners might appreciate the smoother action of the 686, while experienced shooters might prefer the more substantial feel of the GP100.
- Ergonomics: Try to handle both revolvers if possible to determine which feels more comfortable in your hand. Grip size and shape can dramatically affect shooting accuracy and comfort.
Ultimately, both the Ruger GP100 and the Smith & Wesson 686 are excellent revolvers. The "better" choice depends entirely on your individual priorities and preferences. Carefully consider the factors outlined above to make an informed decision that best aligns with your shooting needs and style.
